Legal & Ai
Question / Tech Stack Advice
Post
Just a random topic to talk about. If the world is moving towards automation and Ai, especially in contract review. Wouldn’t everyone’s contract reviews be so tight based on risk and other terms that both “LLM” reviews would lock itself out and ruin the deal. Then humans would have to come intervene and negotiate? What would then be the point if the contract review Ai software?
Top comments · 5
- 10↑u/Feisty-Ad-5420That's not how AI contract review works. At all.
- 7↑u/RevolutionaryMeal937AI can be calibrated and guided. If it’s killing your deal, tell it to be less risk averse. Companies that are seriously deploying AI contract review tools need to be documenting institutional preferences, priorities, and risk tolerance to avoid this kind of misalignment. It’s a solvable problem even with current tools. But you should still have a human in the loop, regardless.
- 4↑u/benjamin_j_b_We actually had this come up recently. Two of our customers were working on a deal together, and so our software was editing both sides of the same contract. Of course it doesn't lock itself out, any more than you'd get locked by a paralegal or junior lawyer applying your company's standard preferences. We typically have our customers' first and second round preferences baked into the ai playbook, and after that it would really be up to a human lawyer to look at to review in case of any remaining conflicts.
- 2↑u/eatoligarchsaldenteThe more realistic end-point is that the AIs hone in on industry standards to a point where contract reviews become extremely tight to just the particular concerns of that customer based on their own unique factors. However, this is all a pipe dream. The reality is that there will continue to be information asymmetries and human elements that will drive negotiations outside of the machine elements. The idea that AIs will govern everything relies on them having access to rich and complete data sets, which is well outside the capabilities of most organizations.
- 2↑u/dreamlegal_legaltechExactly...contracts are ultimately business negotiations, not just risk optimization exercises